Sunday 5 September 2010

Apple patent: helpful or restrictive of rights and privacy?

Apple has applied for a patent named:

"SYSTEMS AND METHODS FOR IDENTIFYING UNAUTHORIZED USERS OF AN ELECTRONIC DEVICE". The full application can be read on the web page below:

http://www.patentvest.com/console/reports/docs/app/20100207721.html

Apple's justification for this patent is that installation of this proposed technology onto their devices will enable identification of unauthorised users, with, the idea that this will help the authorized user should the device fall into the wrong hands, as there is a lot of personal information stored on one of these things, of course.

However, the patent goes way beyond what is necessary to do this and in fact the technology would act as sophisticated spyware if installed on a device. You will see this if you read the application above and the commentary of the ETF:

http://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2010/08/steve-jobs-watching-you-apple-seeking-patent-0

IT geeks and hackers are justifiably concerned about this clause in the application:

"4 . The method of claim 3, wherein the particular activity comprises one or more of hacking the electronic device, jailbreaking the electronic device, unlocking the electronic device, removing a SIM card from the electronic device, and moving at least a predetermined distance away from a synced device"

I agree with the ETF that the application discusses technology that goes way beyond what is necessary for users to recover a lost iphone or ipad. I also think that attempts to prevent IT enthusiasts from breaking into Apple devices so they can potentially modify and experiment with Apple programs etc is a backward step.

1 comment:

Felix Wilson said...

This is quite interesting, thanks Jane.
I know a few people who have "jailbroken" iPods/iPhones and like the extra functionality and its good to be able to make that choice.
How much of a right to control the use of the hardware should Apple have? Some would say none, users should be able to do what they want with it, at their own risk.